Definitions of Acceptable Manuscript Content
Research
A substantial report of a research project in which there is adequate discussion of the research questions, application of appropriate methodology, review of and reference to supporting research literature, and conclusions are clearly stated.The report is original and adds significant information to the field.
Data are reported in clear tables, graphs, and/or charts when necessary.
These manuscripts are reviewed through a normal "double blind" referee process. Neither the author nor the referee is aware of the other's identity or professional standing. Referee comments and recommendations are gathered in writing by the editor. Usually, up to five referees will judge the quality of a manuscript for the initial review.
Rejection by three or more of the referees normally results in rejection of the manuscript for further consideration. The editor may, however, inform the author of referee recommendations for further revision. Manuscripts may be revised and reviewed until a majority of the referees involved and the editor approve the manuscript.
Manuscripts are posted for full board review and majority approval before they are placed online for general public access. Manuscripts are subject to further critical review by any reader of the electronic journal. Constructive comments submitted to the editor may be shared with the author and may be posted as part of the article.
Concept
A substantial, informed statement concerning issues which are of great importance to the field. Such statements will include extensive reference to the research literature where appropriate. A conceptual framework defining emerging theory and/or application of established theory should be evident.Literature Review and Proposal
A substantial, organized, logical and critical review of the key literature supporting a research proposal or summarizing key issues from the research may be acceptable for publication.Such manuscripts should include implications for further research and clearly establish implications for practice.
Manuscripts are subject to the same rigorous referee process as those submitted as research, with the understanding that judgment, while as critical and as extensive, will be adjusted to fit the purpose of the review and proposal.
This manuscript format will be published on a very select basis with manuscripts in research and concept being sought for publication more frequently.
Rights of Publication
Each author, in granting of publication to SLMR, guarantees that the manuscript has not been published/accepted for publication elsewhere. Upon acceptance of an article, each author is required to submit a signed ALA Author Copyright Agreement. Signed copyright agreements for articles accepted for publication in SLMR should be faxed or mailed to:Karen Sheets
ALA Production Services
50 E. Huron St.
Chicago, IL 60611-2795
Fax: 312-280-5280
